← Back to blog
6 min read

What is the difference between a bill of quantities and a schedule of rates?

A bill of quantities gives the measured quantity for every item and gets priced to a total. A schedule of rates fixes the rate and leaves the quantity to be measured later. Which one you use decides who carries the quantity risk.

TL;DR: A bill of quantities lists every item of work with a unit and a measured quantity, and the subcontractor prices each line to get to a total. A schedule of rates lists the items and units with a rate against each, and the quantities are either left blank or marked as estimates, so the final price is the rate times whatever gets measured on site. Use a bill of quantities when the drawings are complete enough to measure. Use a schedule of rates when they aren't yet.

2 quotes come back on the same partitions package. 1 is a lump sum with a priced bill behind it. The other is a page of rates and a line at the bottom that says quantities to be remeasured.

The estimator wants to know which is cheaper. You can't tell yet, because they're 2 different kinds of document.

What is a bill of quantities?

A bill of quantities (BoQ) is a list of every item in the trade, each with a description, a unit and a measured quantity. The subcontractor puts a rate on each line, the lines multiply out, and the total is the price.

Someone has already done the measuring. That's the whole value of it - every subcontractor prices the same 232.7 m² of W3 acoustic partition, so the quotes line up.

In Australia, bills prepared by a quantity surveyor usually follow the Australian and New Zealand Standard Method of Measurement (ANZSMM). Builders doing their own trade bills at tender often use a simpler house format, and that's fine as long as it's the same across the trade.

What is a schedule of rates?

A schedule of rates has the same items and the same units, with a rate against each. The quantities are either blank or marked as estimates.

So there's no fixed total at tender. The work gets measured as it's done and paid at the agreed rate.

You see it where nobody can measure yet. Rock excavation before the geotech is finished. Make-good in an existing building. Maintenance and minor works where the scope turns up week by week.

Here's a synthetic example of the same item in both documents.

DocumentItemUnitQtyRate
Bill of quantitiesW3 acoustic partition, Rw 45m²232.7priced by subcontractor
Schedule of ratesW3 acoustic partition, Rw 45m²estimate onlypriced by subcontractor

Same description, same unit. 1 has a number you can hold someone to.

Who carries the quantity risk?

This is the difference that costs money.

Say the bill has 232.7 m² of W3 and 261 m² gets built. These figures are synthetic.

On a lump sum priced from a bill, the first question is why it moved. If a new revision added walls, that's a variation and the bill rate is the obvious place to start valuing it. If the drawings never changed and the bill was just short, your contract decides who wears the 28.3 m².

On a schedule of rates there's no argument about the quantity. 261 m² gets measured and 261 m² gets paid. The builder carries the quantity and the subcontractor carries the rate.

The standard forms set this out. AS 4000-1997 deals with it in clause 2, with subclauses on the bill of quantities and on adjustment for actual quantities. Read clause 2 and the annexure in your own contract before you rely on either document, because standard forms get amended and this is 1 of the clauses to check.

When should a builder use each one?

Use a bill of quantities when the drawings can be measured. On a documented tender that's partitions, ceilings, waterproofing, doors and floor finishes. You get a fixed price and quotes you can compare line by line.

Use a schedule of rates when the scope is real but the quantity is a guess. If you force a lump sum on unmeasurable work, every subcontractor prices their own guess plus a margin for being wrong, and you pay for that margin whether the rock turns up or it doesn't.

One thing to watch on a schedule of rates. With no quantities, a subcontractor can load the rates on the items they think will grow and drop them on the items they think won't. So put estimated quantities in, even rough ones, and compare the extended totals.

Can you use both on the same package?

Yes.

A common setup is a lump sum backed by a priced bill, with the bill rates doubling as the schedule of rates for variations. A new revision adds 14 m of bulkhead and the rate is already agreed, so the variation is a measurement and a multiplication.

The other setup is a lump sum for the measured work with a short schedule of rates for the provisional items - rock, contaminated spoil, extra fire stopping.

Either way, ask for the rates at tender. They're hard to get once the package is let.

How CIM Build does it

CIM Build reads the drawings and specification into a scope of works for each trade, then measures the quantities against it to build that trade's bill of quantities. Every line has its unit, its quantity and the sheet or clause it came from, and it exports to Excel so you can add rates and send it out with the trade package.

When the quotes come back as lump sums, schedules of rates or 2-page letters, CIM Build levels them against the same trade scope and shows where 1 quote has allowed for work the others left out.

Frequently asked questions

Is a priced bill of quantities the same as a schedule of rates? No. A priced bill has fixed quantities and adds up to a total. A schedule of rates is paid on what gets measured. The rates in a priced bill are often used the way a schedule would be when a variation needs valuing, which is why people mix the 2 names up.

Does a schedule of rates need quantities? It works without them, but put estimates in anyway. With estimated quantities you can extend each quote to a total and see whose rates are loaded onto the items most likely to grow.

Which is easier to compare quotes on? The bill of quantities. Every subcontractor has priced the same measured lines, so a gap between 2 quotes is a rate or an exclusion and you can see which.


Published by CIM.BUILD. This is the text of https://www.cim.build/au/blog/bill-of-quantities-vs-schedule-of-rates without the site design. Index of all pages. Contact.