← Back to blog
5 min read

How do I check a quantity takeoff before pricing?

5 checks to run on any takeoff before rates go on it: the revision, the scale on every sheet, the lines that carry the most cost, whether the quantities agree with each other, and whether every scope item got measured.

TL;DR: Check a takeoff in 5 passes before any rates go on it. Confirm it was measured off the current revision. Confirm the scale on every sheet against a printed dimension. Open the markup on the 3 or 4 lines that carry the most cost and re-measure 1 of them yourself. Compare quantities that should agree, like ceiling area against floor area. Then go down the scope and find every item with no quantity against it.

The Level 3 partitions come back at 290 m². Level 2 is the same floor plate and it measured 579 m².

Nothing changed in the design. The Level 3 plan was an A1 sheet saved down to A3, the title block still said 1:100, and every wall on it measured at half its real length.

That's a synthetic example, but it happens. The checks below are in the order I'd run them, and they work the same whether a cadet, a QS or software did the measuring.

Is it measured off the current revision?

Start here because it's the quickest check and the most expensive one to miss.

Write down the revision of every sheet the takeoff used. Compare that list to the transmittal or the current drawing register. If a sheet has moved on since the measure, find out what changed on it and re-measure those areas.

Clouds help, but they only show what the consultant remembered to cloud. A wall type that changed from W1 to W3 with no cloud is still a different rate.

Is the scale right on every sheet?

Every sheet, one at a time. A set can be 40 sheets at 1:100 and 2 at 1:50, and the 2 are often the wet area layouts.

Pick a dimension printed on the sheet - a grid spacing or an overall building length - and measure it. If the drawing says 8,400 between grids and your tool says 4,200, the scale is wrong.

The half-size one is the first I'd look for. Paper sizes are set by ISO 216, and an A3 sheet is exactly half the width and half the height of an A1. So a 1:100 drawing saved to A3 is really 1:200, and areas off it come out at a quarter.

Any sheet marked "not to scale" or "do not scale" can't be checked this way. Take those quantities from the written dimensions or the schedules, or raise an RFI.

Which lines should I check first?

Don't check every line equally. You won't have time and you'll skim all of them.

Sort the takeoff by what each line is likely to cost and take the top 3 or 4.

For each one, open the markup and look at what was traced. You're looking for runs that stop short, areas that cross a wall they shouldn't, a room missed, the same corridor picked up twice.

Then re-measure 1 of those lines on 1 sheet yourself. If your number and the takeoff's number are close, move on. If they aren't, work out why before you trust anything else on that sheet.

If a line has no markup behind it, you can't check it. You can only trust it or measure it again.

Do the quantities agree with each other?

A building is measured more than once by different trades, so the takeoff can be checked against itself.

None of these will match to the millimetre. A ceiling area that's 30% under the floor area for the same level means something's been missed, or there's an exposed slab nobody told you about. Either way you want to know before you price it.

Is everything in the scope measured?

A takeoff can be right on every line and still be short, because it only holds what somebody thought to measure.

So check it against the scope. Go through the scope of works for the trade, item by item, and find the quantity for each one. An item with no quantity is a gap in the takeoff, or a provisional sum, or work that belongs to another trade. Decide which.

Then do it the other way - take each measured line and find the scope item it sits under. Fire-rated shaft walls, wet area screeds and bulkheads are where I'd look first for work measured in 2 trades or in none.

And check the units while you're there. Partitions in m on 1 level and m² on the next will add up to a number that means nothing.

Checking a takeoff in CIM Build

CIM Build's AI takeoff calibrates each sheet's scale against the dimensions printed on it before it measures, and returns a results table with a marked-up copy of the sheet, so you check it the way you'd check a junior's.

In the bill of quantities each line sits under the scope item it measures, with the sheet or clause it came from, so a scope item with no quantity stands out. And revision tracking compares each new revision against the last one sheet by sheet and lists every change, including the ones nobody clouded.

Frequently asked questions

Who should check a takeoff? Someone other than the person who measured it, if you have the people. If you don't, leave it overnight and check it from the markup, top cost lines first.

How close does a check measure need to be to the takeoff? There's no standard figure I can point you to. Set your own tolerance per trade and write it down, and remember a small percentage on a big line is still a lot of money. If the takeoff feeds a bill of quantities under a contract, check whether the contract states its own limits of accuracy.

Should a takeoff be measured net or with waste included? Net. The ANZSMM measures work net as fixed in place, and waste and laps go in the rates. Mixing the 2 is how a quantity ends up with waste added twice.


Published by CIM.BUILD. This is the text of https://www.cim.build/au/blog/how-to-check-a-quantity-takeoff without the site design. Index of all pages. Contact.