CIM.BUILDBook a demoDemo ↗
7 min read

How to level subcontractor quotes: a worked example

Reconcile original quote totals, compare quantities and scope allowances, and select alternatives without double counting. A synthetic example shows every adjustment.

TL;DR: To level subcontractor quotes, write the trade scope from the drawings and specification first, break each quote into inclusions, exclusions and qualifications, map every line to the scope, and carry an allowance or seek a clarification for each gap before you compare totals. Preserve the original offer, check the quantity and unit basis, and keep alternative prices separate from the selected comparison.

What levelling a quote means

Tender levelling (bid leveling in the US) is the work of bringing every subcontractor quote for a trade onto the same scope, so the prices can be compared fairly. Subcontractors price in their own format and to their own reading of the documents. Until each quote is measured against the same scope, the comparison is between different jobs.

The method

  1. Write the scope before the quotes arrive. Build a scope register for the trade from the drawings and specification, with the sheet or clause behind each line. This is the yardstick every quote is measured against.
  2. Break each quote down. Pull out what it includes, what it excludes, its provisional sums and its qualifications. Exclusions are often on the last page of a covering letter.
  3. Map every line to the register. For each scope item, mark each quote as included, excluded or silent. Silent items carry the most risk, because the subcontractor hasn't said either way.
  4. Price the gaps. For each exclusion or silent item, carry your own allowance or send a clarification asking the subcontractor to confirm. Record which one you chose and why.
  5. Compare the adjusted totals. Only now compare prices, each one adjusted to the full scope.
  6. Keep the record. The levelling sheet becomes the reference when the package is let and when a claim arrives later.

A cheaper quote can become the more expensive comparison

Two subcontractors can quote the same package and still price different work. One has used a smaller quantity. Another includes testing. Both leave an interface with the next trade unclear.

The useful comparison is the cost of the same reviewed scope, with each adjustment visible. Preserve the subcontractor’s original offer alongside that comparison. Otherwise, a plugged allowance can start looking like something the subcontractor agreed to deliver.

Start with the same basis

Before adjusting prices, record the drawing and specification issues, package boundaries, quantities and units being compared. Check whether the offer is a lump sum, a schedule of rates or another pricing basis.

A rate only helps when it applies to the same item and conditions. Do not turn a lump-sum quote into a remeasurable offer by multiplying a rate that was never agreed. A discrepancy in quantity needs a clarification when its pricing treatment is unclear.

The example below assumes both suppliers have quoted usable rates for the same defined work. All figures, quantities and suppliers are synthetic, in Australian dollars excluding GST. They illustrate a review method, not market rates or a customer outcome.

Work through the comparison

The builder’s review basis is 1,000 units of the defined work, mobilisation, specified testing and one package interface.

Original offerSupplier ASupplier B
Main work900 units × $120 = $108,0001,000 units × $115 = $115,000
Mobilisation$12,000$12,000
Specified testingExcluded$18,000 included
Package interfaceSilentSilent
Original quoted total$120,000$145,000

The original lines add back to each quoted total. That sum-back is the first check. It does not prove that all required scope is included.

Supplier A looks $25,000 cheaper on the cover page. To compare the defined scope, the estimator records three adjustments:

  • $12,000 for the additional 100 units, using A’s quoted $120 rate on the stated example assumptions.

  • An $18,000 builder allowance for A’s excluded testing.

  • A $6,000 builder allowance for the unresolved interface in each offer.

Comparison bridgeSupplier ASupplier B
Original quoted total$120,000$145,000
Quantity adjustment+$12,000$0
Testing adjustment+$18,000$0
Interface adjustment+$6,000+$6,000
Reviewed comparison total$156,000$151,000

On those assumptions, B is $5,000 lower. These are comparison totals, not revised subcontractor offers or an award recommendation. Schedule, qualifications, capability and unresolved scope still need review.

Treat silent scope differently from an exclusion

An exclusion is something the subcontractor has explicitly left out. Silence means the offer has not answered the question. Keep those states visible, even if both receive an allowance during tender review.

In this example, the testing exclusion needs a decision about who will deliver it and at what price. The silent interface needs both suppliers to confirm their position. A plug protects the comparison from an unpriced assumption; it does not make the work part of the subcontract.

If a response changes the allowance, preserve the previous value, the response and the reviewer’s reason. That makes the final package understandable to the person buying it later.

Keep alternatives outside the selected total

Suppose B also offers an alternative main-work price of $109,000, replacing its $115,000 base item. Record the alternative separately until its scope and acceptability are reviewed.

If that alternative is accepted for this example, replace the $115,000 line with $109,000. B’s comparison becomes $145,000: $109,000 main work + $12,000 mobilisation + $18,000 testing + $6,000 interface allowance. Do not add both options or subtract the full $109,000 from the base total.

Keep the base comparison available. A lower alternative price may describe different work, and the commercial team needs to see that difference before choosing it.

Leave a record the next person can follow

For every adjustment, retain:

  • The scope item and relevant drawing or specification issue

  • The original quote reference, amount, quantity and unit

  • Whether the item is included, excluded, silent or an alternative

  • The comparison adjustment, its pricing basis and its owner

  • The clarification, response, reviewer and decision date

  • Whether the adjustment is a builder allowance or an agreed supplier price

Before letting the package, resolve or explicitly carry the remaining assumptions through the builder’s normal approval process. Recheck the accepted quote and final scope together. A tidy comparison sheet is not a substitute for confirming what has actually been agreed.

Where CIM.BUILD fits

CIM.BUILD’s bid-levelling workflow helps bring quote information into a comparable view against the trade scope. The estimator still needs to check the source, confirm the pricing basis and decide how each difference is treated.

This is part of how we approach Construction Intelligence Management: keep the documents, findings and reviewed decisions connected so the next person can understand how the package was priced.

A useful evaluation is a real package with deliberately different quantities, a scope exclusion and an alternative. Check whether the team can trace the original offer, explain every adjustment and reconcile the selected total. The output should make the decision easier to inspect.

Read more about CIM.BUILD's tender levelling workflow, preparing the scope of works, and checking tender-to-contract changes.

The allowances that most often go missing

  • Testing and certification. Pile load testing, pressure testing, commissioning and certificates.
  • Attendance and access. Cranage, scaffold, hoists and site amenities.
  • Disposal. Spoil removal and waste classification.
  • Interfaces with other trades. Work between two packages, such as screed between waterproofing and tiling, that each quote assumes belongs to the other.
  • Revision drift. A quote priced to an earlier revision than the current set.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between tender levelling and bid levelling?

They are the same work. Tender levelling is the Australian and UK term, and bid leveling is the US term.

How many subcontractor quotes should I level for each trade?

Most builders aim for at least 3 compliant quotes per trade, so the comparison shows where one quote is out of line with the others.

Should I plug a gap with my own rate or ask the subcontractor?

Ask when the item is significant or unclear, and carry your own allowance when the tender deadline doesn't leave time for an answer. Either way, record the decision against the scope line so it can be checked later.

Can software level quotes without an estimator?

Software can help organise quote information against a scope. The estimator still checks the original offer, confirms the pricing basis and decides how each gap is priced, because that decision depends on the job, the subcontractor and the risk the builder is prepared to carry.